• Hi there and welcome to PC Help Forum (PCHF), a more effective way to get the Tech Support you need!
    We have Experts in all areas of Tech, including Malware Removal, Crash Fixing and BSOD's , Microsoft Windows, Computer DIY and PC Hardware, Networking, Gaming, Tablets and iPads, General and Specific Software Support and so much more.

    Why not Click Here To Sign Up and start enjoying great FREE Tech Support.

    This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Solved MOBO replacement

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi Al! I'm new to this forum and am seeking assistance with replacement of my MSI motherboard - GL63 9SDK model - 16P71 ver. 1 is printed on the motherboard. Windows 10. About 6 weeks ago I started having intermittent operational and crashing problems. I tried the Windows 10 restore procedure and it ultimately caused a complete unrestorable crashed situation. I sent the laptop to the MSI factory service center in CA. They diagnosed it needs another motherboard. Price tag was way more than what would be prudent compared to the computer's worth after the repair.

I have many year's experience working on digital electronics components - (now retired). I would like to replace the motherboard with one of the many that are available online and taken from working laptops. My questions are, which part numbers on the motherboard do I need to use to locate an appropriate replacement and does this repair make sense?

There are may MSI laptops that use the same circuit board layout as my bad board, however they often have many different part numbers.

Any help will be appreciated. Joely
 
G'day Joel and welcome to the forums.

first up, how old is this laptop, and is the expenditure in time and money going to be worth it?
I'll assume the rig is out of warranty?

I'm thinking, even if the problem is only the motherboard, that component alone is going to be around a quarter the price of a new unit.
It would be a bugger to replace that only to find something else is at fault as well, like the processor.

so while dearer to buy a new laptop, is the end result better bang for your buck!
 
Hi Bruce, thanks for the reply. The dead laptop was built in 2019, and yes, it's out of warranty. Any MOBO I would get will come with the i7 CPU and the separate Nvidia graphics chip. This is one reason the available working MOBOs are anywhere from about $250 to $800. I figure if I can get a working replacement MOBO for around $300 to $400 including the afore mentioned i7 CPU (9th gen) along with the appropriate Nvidia 1660 ti Graphics card, I can put everything back together in a couple of hours. Yes, there will be other work to get OS reloaded, but it would be nice to have a working spare laptop that would run circles around the old Toshiba.

I needed another laptop because I use one everyday. I relied on a very old Toshiba, that still works like a charm, until the replacement arrived. I got a newer, faster, larger, all around better version of the one that died for a little over $800. It is very clean and seems to have little use on it.

My main question is, which part number on the replacement motherboard do I need to use to locate an appropriate replacement. Is it imperative that I find another MOBO with the exact same part number as the one that failed? Or, will another MOBO that uses the exact same circuit board, but with a different part number possibly work?

If I can't get another MOBO for the dead laptop, I'll most likely part it out on eBay.

Thanks again.
 
The other thing that you need to think of is RAM that will match the specs for the CPU and Motherboard.

Not including the power supply that may need to be replace that will match the input and requirements for the new motherboard.

Finally, will it fit into the laptop case.

Buying a motherboard for laptop is not as universal as it is for a desktop. Even still then we have to make sure things match properly.
 
Thank you, Rustys. I had thought of those things and I appreciate you mentioning them. Besides the three items you mentioned, I want to make sure the new MOBO supports individual RGB keyboard lighting and that it is configured to drive a 15.6" display (1920 X 1080 wide display). The physical size and shape are the easiest to confirm. Thanks again.
 
sorry Joel, I've gotta say that if it was mine, once you get down to the motherboard level on laptops, I walk away.
they build the buggers to all go together, and once you start changing out parts that are not the same, it can have a cascade effect, making you update other components, like RAM, power, etc.
and unless you do get the same mobo, you run into compatibility issues with all the data connection ribbons on the mobo for drives, touchpad, keyboard, screen, speakers.
then there are those 'mini-boards', like for power, USB ports, etc.

so, if you match the part numbers, you have a good chance, otherwise before you know it, you are on a slippery slope of replacing more than you'd bargain for and at a comparable cost of a new unit.

sure, money not outstanding, it would be a nice exercise to sink your teeth into. but laptops and I have never played nice together and I'll admit, I've damaged more of those friggin data ribbon cables than I care to mention! so I'm probably biased against working on laptops unless it's the mundane swapping memory or drive issues.
 
Thanks Bruce. Your comments are exactly what I was looking for! I too have made knucklehead decisions and as a mentor once told me, "pain teaches". I'm leaning more toward the "part it out" approach. It certainly has the potential of being more cost effective. Thank you for your candid response. It's appreciated.
 
As of now, no. I'm not planning to tackle the project now, but if I find one cheap enough, I still may entertain the idea of trying to change it out. Currently, I've got too many other projects to pursue this one. I've salvaged all of the old files from backups, so this is not a burning issue. Thanks again for your input!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.